We supply and install all three, so this is the comparison we give clients, not a pitch: every current line from each brand in one table, what each brand is best at, what you give up, and which one we reach for on a landmark facade, a custom house, a gut renovation and a rental.
In short: All three make good windows, and we supply and install all three, so this is not a sales pitch for one. The short version: Marvin is the choice when the window is an architectural element, with the widest custom sizing, the largest units, the best modern and landmark-replica options and the highest prices; Pella is the choice when you want a wide range of looks and price points from one maker, with strong wood lines (Reserve, Lifestyle) at the top and fiberglass and vinyl lines below; Andersen is the choice for a dependable, widely stocked, mid-priced wood or composite window with the shortest lead times and the easiest service, and for coastal and impact ratings. In New York the decision usually comes down to three things: whether the opening is in a landmark district, whether you need a custom size or a very large unit, and how much of the budget the windows can take. We put the three side by side below, line by line, and say which one we reach for in each situation.
| Marvin | Pella | Andersen | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Top wood line | Ultimate (wood interior, extruded aluminum or wood exterior) | Reserve Traditional and Reserve Contemporary (wood, aluminum-clad) | E-Series (wood interior, aluminum-clad exterior, custom colors) |
| Mid wood or clad line | Elevate (wood interior, Ultrex fiberglass exterior) | Lifestyle Series (wood interior, aluminum-clad exterior) | 400 Series (wood interior, vinyl-clad Perma-Shield exterior); A-Series (wood interior, Fibrex exterior) |
| Fiberglass or composite | Essential (Ultrex fiberglass in and out); Vivid (fiberglass composite, large sizes) | Impervia (fiberglass) | 100 Series (Fibrex composite in and out) |
| Vinyl | None | 250 Series, Encompass, Defender and Hurricane Shield (impact) | 200 Series (vinyl-clad wood); no all-vinyl line under the Andersen name |
| Modern or steel-look line | Modern (aluminum interior, high-density fiberglass exterior, narrow sightlines) | Reserve Contemporary | E-Series with narrow profiles; Andersen Aluminum (formerly Heritage) |
| Custom sizes and shapes | Widest: Ultimate and Modern are built to order; large multi-slide and lift-and-slide doors | Good in Reserve and Lifestyle; limited in Impervia and vinyl | Good in E-Series and A-Series; standard sizes in 400, 200 and 100 |
| Exterior colors | 19 standard plus custom; wood exteriors in four species | Many standard colors; custom on Reserve | E-Series custom colors; fixed palettes on 400 and 100 |
| Landmark replacement in NYC | Ultimate wood double-hung and casement with true or simulated divided lites; the most-approved profile | Reserve Traditional with through-stile construction; approved on many filings | E-Series and 400 Series Woodwright with divided lites; approved on many filings |
| Impact and coastal | Ultimate with IZ3 and PG50 options | Hurricane Shield and Defender (vinyl); impact options on wood lines | Stormwatch impact options across 400, A and E-Series; strong coastal catalog |
| Lead time (typical, not a promise) | Longest on Ultimate and Modern; weeks to months | Moderate; Reserve longer than Lifestyle | Shortest on 400 and 100; many sizes stocked regionally |
| Price position | Highest | Wide: from vinyl to premium wood | Mid, with E-Series reaching premium |
| Where we have installed it | Manhattan and Brooklyn townhouses (Ultimate), Clinton Hill | Carroll Gardens landmark house, Manhattan Beach new house | Supply and service across Brooklyn, Queens and Long Island |
Line names change. Marvin now lists five collections (Ultimate, Modern, Vivid, Elevate, Essential) and has dropped the "Signature" umbrella it used until recently; Pella's wood lines are Reserve and Lifestyle, with Architect Series folded into Reserve; Andersen still runs E-Series, A-Series, 400, 200 and 100 plus Andersen Aluminum. We check the current catalog at the time of order, because the quote has to name the line the factory will build.

Marvin's Ultimate line is what architects draw when they want a wood window with exact proportions: custom sizes to the eighth of an inch, deep wood interiors in six species, true divided lites, and hardware that reads as furniture. The Modern line is the only mainstream wood-brand product that competes with steel and aluminum for narrow sightlines, and the Vivid line, new in 2025, brings Marvin's larger sizes into a fiberglass composite at a lower price than Ultimate. Elevate and Essential are the fiberglass-exterior lines for budgets that still want the Marvin look; the differences between them are in Marvin Ultimate vs Elevate vs Essential.
What you pay for: the widest range, the largest units, the most-approved landmark profiles, and finishes that match a custom house. What you give up: lead time and price. On a townhouse rebuild, a landmark replacement or a house where the architect has drawn every window, Marvin is the default; see Marvin windows and the East 70th Street and Clinton Hill projects.

Pella's strength is breadth. Reserve Traditional is a wood window with through-stile construction that stands next to Marvin Ultimate on a landmark filing; Reserve Contemporary is the clean-lined version; Lifestyle is the wood line most houses actually get, with the option of blinds and shades between the glass; Impervia is a fiberglass window with a long warranty; and 250 Series, Encompass, Defender and Hurricane Shield cover vinyl from budget to impact-rated. One brand can therefore do the street facade in Reserve and the rear and side elevations in Lifestyle or Impervia, with matching colors, which is how we specified the Carroll Gardens landmark house and the Manhattan Beach new house. Which Pella line fits which job is in Pella Reserve vs Lifestyle vs Impervia vs 250 Series; the product page is Pella windows.
What you give up: custom sizing is narrower than Marvin's on the lower lines, and the brand sells partly through its own branches, so service on a Pella window depends on who installed it. We install and service Pella as an independent installer across the five boroughs and New Jersey.

Andersen's 400 Series is the most common wood window in the suburbs for a reason: a wood interior, a vinyl-clad exterior that does not need paint, a catalog of standard sizes that a lumber yard can have in days, and a parts and service network that will still have the sash and hardware twenty years from now. The 100 Series Fibrex composite is a step below in price and a step above vinyl in stiffness and color stability. A-Series puts a Fibrex exterior on a wood interior with more styles; E-Series is Andersen's custom aluminum-clad wood line and is the one to compare with Marvin Ultimate and Pella Reserve. Andersen's coastal and impact (Stormwatch) catalog is the broadest of the three, which matters on Long Island and the Jersey Shore.
What you give up: fewer custom options and a more standard look on 400 and 100, and the vinyl-clad exterior of the 400 Series, which some architects and landmark reviewers prefer not to see on a street facade. See Andersen windows.
| Situation | Our usual recommendation | Why |
|---|---|---|
| Landmark townhouse facade, Manhattan or Brooklyn | Marvin Ultimate or Pella Reserve Traditional | Wood double-hung with the profiles the Landmarks Preservation Commission has approved before; both file cleanly |
| Architect-designed house, custom sizes, large units | Marvin Ultimate or Modern; Andersen E-Series as the alternate | Custom sizing and large multi-slide and lift-and-slide doors |
| Modern house or addition, narrow sightlines | Marvin Modern; Pella Reserve Contemporary | The only wood-brand lines that compete with aluminum sightlines |
| Gut renovation, good budget, not landmarked | Pella Lifestyle or Marvin Elevate; Andersen 400 as the value option | Wood interior, low-maintenance exterior, mid price |
| Rental building or flip, wood look required | Andersen 400 or 200; Pella Lifestyle | Stocked sizes, short lead time, serviceable |
| No wood wanted, low maintenance | Marvin Essential or Vivid, Pella Impervia, Andersen 100 | Fiberglass or composite in and out |
| Budget, vinyl acceptable | Pella 250 Series or Encompass | Andersen and Marvin do not make an all-vinyl window |
| Coastal, impact-rated | Andersen Stormwatch (400, A, E); Pella Hurricane Shield; Marvin Ultimate IZ3 | Broadest impact catalogs in that order |
| Fast replacement, one or two windows | Andersen 400 or 100 from stock | Days, not weeks |
Two notes that apply to all three. First, the glass matters as much as the brand: every line can be ordered with the low-E and argon unit the New York energy code expects, and the whole-window U-factor on the NFRC label is what the plan examiner reads; see low-E glass. Second, the installation is not the brand's job. A Marvin window set without a sill pan leaks like any other; the warranty on all three depends on installation per the instructions, and that is what we are responsible for.
Send the window schedule or a photo of each elevation with rough sizes, say whether the building is landmarked, and tell us the look you want (painted wood inside, stained, no wood). We come back with the line from each brand that fits, side by side, with the lead time and the price per opening, and with the samples at the showroom in St. George. We supply and install Marvin, Pella and Andersen across the five boroughs, Long Island and New Jersey, and we also replace the glass and moldings in all three when a unit fails. request a quote.
Neither across the board. Marvin has the widest custom sizing, the largest units and the most modern and landmark-replica options at the highest price; Pella has the widest range of looks and prices from one maker, from Reserve wood to vinyl. For a landmark facade both file well; for an architect-drawn custom house Marvin; for mixed budgets on one house Pella.
Usually, on the 400, 200 and 100 Series, which are standard-size, widely stocked lines. Andersen E-Series is a premium custom line priced with Marvin Ultimate and Pella Reserve.
All three have wood double-hung and casement lines with profiles that have been approved on many filings: Marvin Ultimate, Pella Reserve Traditional and Andersen E-Series or 400 Woodwright. Approval is per filing, based on the drawings and the existing window.
Andersen 400 and 100 Series, which are stocked in standard sizes. Marvin Ultimate and Modern are built to order and take the longest.
Pella (250 Series, Encompass, Defender, Hurricane Shield). Marvin makes no vinyl; Andersen's 200 and 400 Series are vinyl-clad wood, not vinyl.
Marvin Modern for the narrowest wood-brand sightlines, then Pella Reserve Contemporary and Andersen E-Series. For true steel or aluminum sightlines, an aluminum or steel system may fit better; we install those too.
Yes. We supply and install Marvin, Pella and Andersen windows and doors across New York City, Long Island and New Jersey, and we service and reglaze all three.
The installation. All three brands warrant the window only when it is installed per their instructions, with a sill pan and proper flashing; most leaks we inspect are installation faults, not window faults.
Marvin windows Pella windows Andersen windows Marvin Ultimate vs Elevate vs Essential Pella lines compared Wood and clad windows Aluminum vs uPVC vs wood
About this page. Written by Alex GC Inc. d/b/a Alex Glass Construction and reviewed before publication by Aleksandr Chernovolenko, Managing Partner, with our design and estimating lead and a field foreman. Our foremen hold the NYC DOB Site Safety Training supervisor card and our crews the 40-hour worker card; we are certified to fabricate, install and service Alutech and Everest aluminum systems. Facts are drawn from our own projects, manufacturer test data and the applicable codes; where we are giving an opinion, we say so. Last reviewed November 2026. Credentials
Send the window schedule or elevation photos and tell us the look and the budget. We quote the matching line from each brand side by side, with lead times.